Progressive and Allstate flagged by BMO over AI-driven threat to auto insurance
BMO flags two major insurers as exposed to autonomous-vehicle disruption
BMO Capital Markets told clients that advances in vehicle autonomy could materially change the addressable market for personal auto coverage, and investors should take note of carriers concentrated in that line. The bank projects a market peak near $560 billion by 2040, then anticipates a steady contraction averaging about 4% per year over the following decade.
The research note argues the largest structural driver is accident frequency falling as autonomous systems proliferate, with full autonomy modeled to cut collisions by 75–90%. Even today's advanced driver-assistance systems are not trivial: BMO attributes as much as a 40% reduction in collisions to current ADAS technology, which already nudges loss trends.
Because corporate valuations embed long-term growth assumptions, BMO warns that downward revisions to terminal growth can compress insurance multiples well before claim volumes actually shrink. Progressive stands out under this lens because more than 90% of its premiums come from auto lines, a concentration the note highlights as a vulnerability; the stock has fallen in the year to date by roughly 11%, even as analyst targets show potential upside.
Allstate is also singled out: about two-thirds of its written premiums come from private auto, and its shares are down modestly this year by around 2%. Yet consensus price targets still imply north of 18–19% upside for both carriers, a split between near-term optimism and longer-term structural concern.
BMO contrasts these exposures with firms that have little or no retail auto footprint — such as Fidelis, Hamilton, Kinsale and RenaissanceRe — which could avoid the same degree of downside pressure as personal auto volumes ebb.
Investors are therefore being asked to weigh two timelines at once: when autonomous technology meaningfully reduces loss frequency, and when the market will pre-emptively reprice insurers because of lower terminal growth expectations.
- Watch metrics that will drive repricing: collision frequency, ADAS adoption rates, and changes in average claim severity.
- Expect companies with concentrated auto portfolios to face valuation compression ahead of actual premium erosion.
- Specialty carriers and reinsurers with limited personal-auto exposure may gain relative appeal as the market reassesses risk mix.
Read Our Expert Analysis
Create an account or login for free to unlock our expert analysis and key takeaways for this development.
By continuing, you agree to receive marketing communications and our weekly newsletter. You can opt-out at any time.
Recommended for you
Automakers selling driver telemetry to insurers fuels privacy and pricing fights
A driver discovered his braking event reached an insurer via his vehicle maker’s telemetry, sparking a lawsuit and renewed scrutiny of data sales. Regulators and consumer groups warn that widespread collection—affecting roughly nine in ten new cars—has real price and consent implications.
Blackstone Executive Flags Artificial Intelligence as the Prime Disruption Threat to Portfolios
A senior Blackstone executive warns that rapid advances in artificial intelligence pose the largest disruption risk to asset fundamentals, prompting the firm to embed faster obsolescence scenarios and operational playbooks into underwriting. Market signals — from heavy upstream AI infrastructure bookings and memory reallocations to credit-market repricing of software names — are sharpening the urgency for private capital to reassess hold periods, capital allocation and policy exposure.
